Monday, April 19, 2010

Essay 3.2 Finding a Place in this World

November 15, 2007 was a cold but clear Thursday in my hometown of Sykesville MD. It started out like every other day but strong emotions hung in the air of Century High School, at least for the members of the Century Marching Knights. November 15th would be forever remembered as the day we would become National Champions under the United States Scholastic Band Association (USSBA). We were told to report to school by 7am and meet in the band room for an attendance check. It was still dark outside but the band was all there, wide awake, and huddled together in the band room waiting for morning announcements to begin so we could start the biggest day of our marching band careers. We finished out our days per usual and then headed out behind the school for last minute preparations before we set out for Raven’s Stadium in Baltimore. The whole community lined up for our notorious final run through at the end of our rehearsal. We had our principal, fellow peers, newspaper reporters, family, and even some teachers stay to watch us and wish us well at nationals. As we loaded the bus everyone was silent, going through the show in their heads ready to lay it all down on the field that night at 11:27pm. When we arrived at M&T Bank Stadium it was 31o outside and it was only 8:30. That left us with a 2 ½ hour warm up block in the freezing cold. We took our time and then made our way to the field. With nothing but the performance on our minds we took the field and threw it down. We nailed everything, and we knew it too. After we finished the crowd went crazy, we’d won them over. As we left the field we couldn’t do anything but smile. It was the best show we had ever given and all our long difficult practices paid off. With a total score of 96.75, out of 100, we won 1st place by 2 points. At this moment in my life I felt like I had finally found somewhere that I belonged. I felt like I fit in here and I couldn’t have been more proud of what I accomplished. I can’t even imagine my life without the friends I’ve made along the way and the achievements I’ve accomplished.

Things weren’t always this clear for me. Back in middle school I didn’t know who I wanted to be. I mean what middle school adolescent does? All I knew was that I needed to find my clique in school. I had always been known as the sports star in my small middle school, but I knew I wasn’t good enough to play in high school. It wasn’t until I met my mathematics teacher in 7th grade, Mr. Oppenheimer, that I would find out just where my high school career and beyond would take me. He gave us a simple assignment; find something in your everyday life where mathematics can be applied to solve a problem and write a 1200 word essay explaining why and how math can/is used. Now it’s important to know that my brother had just joined a marching band at his high school, and anything he did I always wanted to do, because I looked up to him so much. With that being said I decided to apply mathematics to marching band and drill design and formation. This small assignment sparked my passion for competitive colorguard. I wanted to know how it worked, what went into it, techniques, styles, individual limitations, how the different sections worked independently and then came together as a whole. I was hooked and there was no looking back. That 1200 word essay turned into a 6 page paper and my teacher told me that if I didn’t step out of my comfort zone, get involved with the band, and get the experience I was craving, then I would always regret it. So I did what he said.

I see now that getting involved in marching band truly shaped me into the person I am today. I got involved at such a crucial point in my life and if I hadn’t taken that chance when I did I know I would be a completely different person then I am now. In my psychology class we are learning about the life-span of a human, and individual development processes. We’re learning about the different stages of life and how different influences during these life stages can affect the final outcome of a person’s personality, style, and interests. We’ve learned that childhood is a time of learning. Kids are like sponges and whatever they are surrounded with they will soak up and will ultimately become what they are influenced by. Studies that were published in the Journal of Adolescent Research stated that individual surroundings for the middle and high school years did help foretell what type of lifestyle a young adult would have (Stone 3). Children don’t just wake up one morning and decide to become something totally different then what they have grown up around. Their experiences along the road of adolescents shape them and create their personality. Stone also goes on to describe that social identity or “the sense of one’s place in the social world” really dictates where that adolescent will end up in a few years. One’s social identity controls who you hang out with, the activities you participate in, and the experiences you are exposed to.

I was always involved in sports such as basketball and football, which helped spark my interest in sports as a young adult today, but marching band created something for me that I had never experienced before. It taught me so much and showed me that I can do something well. In middle school I was always told that I was good at basketball or I was a good public speaker, but I never really felt like those came easily to me, and that I could accomplish anything in those fields. However, when I joined marching band and I started colorguard practice I soon found out that I was truly good at guard. Marching band was somewhere I belonged. I was confident there and it came easily to me. I was always self conscious, and still am to this day, but in colorguard I didn’t have to be. I could push the limits to what I could do, try new tricks, show off even. That was something I had never been able to do before and it made me have a new found confidence that helped me really turn into the person I am today. I don’t think I would have had the confidence I do now if I had never been exposed to colorguard; and just think I would have never gotten involved in marching band if it weren’t for my 7th grade math teacher.

Music and the arts gave me opportunities I could never even dream of. The art of performance and expression really helped me throughout my high school years. I am usually pretty shy until I really get to know someone, but in colorguard I didn’t have to be. I could walk onto the field and be completely confident in what I was doing. That’s something I thought I would never have. According to Child Trends Databank online, which is a webpage dedicated to exploring adolescents trends, said that kids who participate in some aspect of the performing arts do better in school, avoid getting into serious trouble, and are more disciplined (Participation in School Music or Other Performing Arts, n.pag). I can personally say that marching band has molded me into the individual I am today. My friends along the way have helped me so much and I don’t know where my life would have taken me had I not taken that leap of faith back in middle school. After joining band my grades did seem to improve a bit and I felt like I had more structure in my life. I learned that I needed to stay busy in order to be successful, and that’s still true to this day. Colorguard was such a huge commitment that I had to stay focused and disciplined or I would have lost control of my school work and personal life. However, I did work hard and I did keep up and I think it was those commitments and strict discipline that got me in JMU. My grades were ok, but my extracurricular activities really stood out to the admissions board to ultimately got me accepted into my top choice ‘reach school’.

Participation in School Music or Other Performing Arts. Child Trends DataBank. 2010. Child Trends. Web. 12 April 2010.

Stone, Margart R. Barber, Bonnie L. Eccles, Jacquelynne S. “We Knew Them When: Sixth Grade Characteristics That Predict Adolescent High School Social Identities”. The Journal of Early Adolescents. 28. 304(2008): 26. Web.

14 comments:

  1. Kara,
    I really enjoyed reading your paper for the second time. I thought it had more of a fluid feel and it was much more engaging after you moved some things around. I love the opening sentence in your essay because it keeps the audience interested and makes us want to know what happened on that date. I would suggest possibly putting the sources a little sooner in the paper. Maybe a quote from your coach or a captain? Maybe even a quote from a friend in marching band? It would also be a primary source which would be great. I would also strongly suggest a few more sources for your paper. A couple of statistics or even personal quotes from a website or something would be good. For this sort of paper, I don’t suggest you add any more scholarly sources, but a website one would be great! I really couldn’t find anything else so say about it since I commented on your first draft and this isn’t but so different since you haven’t had peer evaluation day yet. Good work and good luck on the final draft!
    Thanks,
    Katelyn

    ReplyDelete
  2. Kara,
    This is a really interesting paper. I loved your opening paragraph, it got me hooked into the paper and I wanted to read more and more to find out what happened on that date. It sounds like such an amazing experience from what you write about that it almost makes the reader want to be there watching the marching band since you all seem to have done such an amazing job. You describe the situation very well and your voice comes through very strongly. Some suggestions I have for you would be to make the paper even a little more personal. It is already a great narrative but if you could describe even more about how the band influenced your life that would be great, maybe describe how you think it will impact you in college since you said it helped you get into the school. I agree with Katelyn in the above comment that some more sources would be nice, like quotes. This would further enhance your paper. It would be good to have more sources because this paper does tell such a good story that it needs a little more backing up. Overall I really cant find too much wrong with this paper, I truly think it is great and with just a little work you will have an awesome final draft!- Olivia Miller

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kara,

    I really liked your paper and thought it was effective. I really liked your introduction and just way of telling the story. The sensory details were great and helped picture the scene.

    But, I think you could strengthen the overall argument. I'm kind of confused what you're arguing. How marching band helped you? or just to get involved? I think your last paragraph could be added to and separated. I just think the final argument and conclusion needs more.

    I'm assuming you also know you need more sources. I think sources relating to students who don't get involved in organizations and maybe the other side would be helpful.

    Good luck on your next draft!

    Danielle

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kara,
    Your paper topic was really good. I really liked how you started out the paper by telling your story. I also liked how you followed up by telling another story. I think that your detail also helped to grasp my attention because I felt like I was actually experiencing what you were experiencing.
    I think there are a couple of things you could do to imporve your paper. Although the assignment is a narrative argument, it is stil an arguement and I was kind of confused as to what your arguement was. I know you said you felt like you didn't fit in but are you arguing that people should find something that they fit into? just make sure to make your arguement clear. Also because there was so much of your own story being told, there was no room to fit in facts or very little room to fit them, so sources in your paper were very limited. I think once you state the argument it will be alot easier to use sources and incorporate them into your paper. Also when putting quotes into your paper make sure to add quotation marks around the actual quote. Other than that great job and good luck on your final draft.
    Ashley

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Kara,

    I thought you did a really good job on your essay. I loved how passionate you were and it really showed in your voice throughout the paper. I liked how it was alot of your own voice and your own personal story, it was very moving.

    But I think there are some things you can improve on. The citations are one, make sure to always cite quotes. Also I think there should be a better transition about talking about children starting something at a young age because I found it a little confusing. So just maybe smooth up the transitions.

    Other than that I thought it was great. Good luck on the final draft!

    Railey Hiser

    ReplyDelete
  6. I liked your paper and the things that you talked about in it. It was filled with a lot of your emotions and your voice was very consistent.I feel that there are a few things that you can work on and change. I'm really not too sure of what your argument is in your paper. It would be great if you clarify what your arguing somewhere in your introduction and then continue to follow it up throughout your paper. The research that you performed and used was great but you need to add at least one more to meet the requirement for this assignment. I think some statistics that are relevant to your argument would be great to add.Good Job Girl!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Kara

    Good job so far! I like your paper and while I have never been apart of a band I think you provide a rich insight to your readers. I know anyone can relate to your paper because when hasn't someone our age felt lost and I found myself agreeing with a lot of your points. However, I was a little bit confused as to what you were actually saying with your paper. Make it more clear. Say what you want to say. Make it clear and concise and real to readers. Other than the need of some sources, I think you have done well with this assignment and I'm sure you will do even better with your final draft!
    Brooke

    ReplyDelete
  8. Dear, Kara.

    I really enjoyed reading your paper! It is so interesting topic and idea. I like your personal story in the introduction. I think your story is very specific and you really worked well. Through those stories, I could hear your own voices. You follow the rule of the narrative argument which has to include your own voices.
    I want to suggest several things. At first time, it was a little bit hard to find your argument because it was confusing. If you add more sources, it would be help to improve your argument. Also, your introduction and conclusion parts are longer than other paragraphs. If you can make it shorter or separate, it could be easy to catch your idea at first and the end part.
    Overall, I enjoyed reading your paper, and you had nice job.

    Good Luck.
    I hope this comment is helpful to your next draft.

    Minsun

    ReplyDelete
  9. Dear Kara,

    I like your marching band story. I can feel how proud you were when you won first place. I can see that you loved marching band. I also like that you included the details such as the date and the points you received at the contest. This keeps the audience interested. However, when I was reading your first and second paragraphs I couldn't really figure out what your argument is going to be. So I suggest that you make the argument more clear and maybe introduce it earlier in your paper. Also you say "person I am today" many times, so I suggest maybe make the wording a little different on some of them. Good job so far and good luck on your final paper!

    Sora Shin

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hey Kara!

    I'm so glad you wrote about this--it's definitely a unique topic but something that obviously works really well with a narrative argument. You did an excellent job of setting the stage for your audience from the very first paragraph literally opening with the 5 W's but it was something you also carried throughout the essay which was impressive because sometimes that's a hard thing to remember because you're trying to just get the story out. At least that's how it is for me...I've realized I tell stories pretty confusingly, so I have to work on going back and explaining the when, the what, the where, the why, and the how so that the reader can understand even what's happening. So I really appreciated that in your essay. I also thought you had very strong and convincing diction. You used words that painted the picture well like "huddled together", "dark outside", "wide awake" and "won them over" from the first paragraph alone. I almost felt like I was all huddled up with you guys too. My first suggestion involves two sentences that I'm aware of...on in the second paragraph and one in the fourth paragraph respectively. The first one is, "Now it's important to know that my brother had just joined a marching band at his high school, and anything he did I always wanted to do, because I looked up to him so much." I feel like this could be worded a bit better...maybe stating that you looked up to him first before mentioning the fact that he was in his own marching band. I re-read it a few times and it just didn't flow right. The second one is, "I was always self conscious, and still am to this day, but in colorguard I didn't have to be." I'm not sure if I have a suggestion on how to rephrase it, but again, sort of threw me off a little bit. Maybe start with, "Growing up I was always self conscious..." In the final paragraph I feel like you sort of just dropped the participation in performing arts quote in there. There wasn't a lead in, so I was sort of confused and then the follow up didn't come until two sentences later. Consider moving some of those things around to finish strong. I think you have a great thing going here...best of luck on your last draft, Kara!!
    Love, Katie

    ReplyDelete
  11. Dear Kara,

    I enjoyed reading your paper and your topic. I felt your were able to excel in the areas of explaining the narrative story to the reader. You use very good sensory details in order to help the reader try to stand in your own foot steps. I felt your first paragraph was a very good opener. It got me decently hooked because I know that feeling way to well of waiting before a performance. One thing I just wanted to point out is your sources. You are missing one and I just wanted to make sure that you included that in your final draft. Secondly, I felt I lost your argument through some of the paper. I am also running with the same problem of trying to incorporate my story with an argument, but just make sure your argument comes out clearly over the story. Third, I felt the paragraphs were a little to long for my liking. I felt this was a distraction just for me that made my mind drift a little while reading your paper. There is no harm in adding more paragraphs. Other than that, I felt this was a good paper. Good luck with your final draft.

    Bryan Vu

    ReplyDelete
  12. Kara,

    You had an excellent narrative (argument). I thought your story was very well told and flowed well. Your personal testimony and story provided and excellent picture of how your life was altered by participation in the arts. The major problem i encountered with your essay was that the argument part was rather weak and confusing. Your narrative was expertly written but in comparison you spent relatively little time formulating and developing your claim.

    my best guess (because i am not totally sure) of what your claim is, is something along the lines of "participation in the arts is a vital part of a persons education and helps to shape them into a more complete individual"

    my problem is that your claim was never explicitly and even very poorly implicitly stated. This makes the argument kind of confusing because your writing is working without a clear purpose.

    If you can explicitly state your claim earlier in the essay and spend more time developing the argument part of your narrative i think you will have an excellent piece of work here.


    Good Luck
    Tom

    ReplyDelete
  13. Dear Kara,

    First of all, I think you have done a great job improving your paper from your first draft! I really like that you chose this as your topic because marching band was a big part of my life too.

    I really like the descriptive quality of your first paragraph. Like when you describe how quiet it was on the bus ride over, and the exact time you play. Also I like how then, in the second paragraph you go back to how you got interested in marching band. I think that’s a great way of writing your paper.

    The only thing I would add to this paper is another source and maybe even using more of the sources you have already used. Besides that Great job with your second draft and good luck with your final draft of our final paper!!

    Hannah

    ReplyDelete
  14. Kara,

    I enjoyed reading your paper. It was refreshing reading something that you are passionate about and I think you exemplified it well in this paper. This was a great narrative to end the workshops off with because it had all the necessary narrative qualities and you really told your story well. I liked the order of your essay. I like how you talked about winning and then you go into how you became a member of the band. It was a nice use of flashback. One thing that concerns me is how long your introduction paragraph is. It is distracting to a reader. I know when I was reading it I thought at the beginning that you were really engaging me in the paper but then I would get distracted. It was hard to focus on considering it was so long. I think that it would be beneficial to shorten the first paragraph. I know that it is the climax of your story and you want to keep it into one paragraph because after all it does only talk about one night but you should either try shortening it like maybe talk about before the show then talk about during then the end where you won or create an entire new paragraph explaining maybe about nerves and how nervous you were before the show just something to keep the reader involved in the story. My next concern is what you were arguing. In paragraph 3 you talk about how band made you who you are today. So are you arguing that we should be more involved in the arts? Or that we should just be passionate about something in our lives because it shapes who you are as a person? Just make that a little more clear. But other than that I think this is a solid narrative argument. Good luck with your revisions.

    Lauren

    ReplyDelete